Book Review: “Vivek and I” by Mayur Patel – Of Homosexuality and Society

Posted on March 8, 2012

By Anushri Saxena:

Rating: 3/5

STORYLINE: In school-going Vivek’s innocent eyes, Kaushik Mistry was everything an ideal man ought to be like: he was intelligent, wise, and humble, he had an appealing personality, he was successful; in short, he was a complete man, for whom almost everything was achievable and worthwhile. Similar were the thoughts of everyone who knew Kaushik. Yet, he was miserable and nobody, in a minuscule town like Valai, could imagine why.

Caught between the desperate attempts of Vidya, a fellow female colleague’s obstinate demonstrations of love for him and his own dilemmatic love-sickness for Vivek; Kaushik, a 26-year old English teacher from Baroda, finds himself questioning his conscience all the time. Though he is sure of what he wants but hurting others is not characteristic of him either.

A voracious lover of nature and innately sensitive to his surroundings and his dear ones, our protagonist Kaushik goes through a number of phases, to some of which he reacts very humanly; hence, ending up directing himself dissolutely.

Unable to bind his love interests to himself, he is left out, torn and devastated. Moreover, his sexual-orientation poses as a major challenge for him of acceptance by and survival in the sneeringly orthodox society.


I found it a little slow-paced; I had never read anything like this which dealt with such a sensitive topic as homosexuality. Author Mayur Patel has tried well to maintain the curiosity factor by seasoning the story with cricket, local teenage spectacles and a persistent threat by a beast on the loose from a jungle.

It surely is a promising plot; however, I, personally do not read a lot of “mush stuff”, so I found it only a little agonizing at some points. The narrative gives an insight of the Western Indian and South-Western Indian cultures (mainly Gujarat, Maharashtra and Kerala), enlightening the reader with the composition of some of the local traditions; like the cuisine of the people and the annual fun melas of Holi. It also draws a subtle distinction between the urban and the rural lifestyles and general nature of people found in the two parts.

Recommended to those passionate for chick-literature, those who would like to attempt to appreciate a topic as perceptive as homosexuality and to those who simply like to experiment with their reads.

P.S. The book incorporates some syntactical and grammatical errors in due course of its narration.

Youth Ki Awaaz

India's largest platform for young people to express themselves on critical issues - making best use of new media and online journalism.

Submit Your Story


You must be logged in to comment.

If you sign up with Google, Twitter or Facebook, we’ll automatically import your bio which you will be able to edit/change after logging in. Also, we’ll never post to Twitter or Facebook without your permission. We take privacy very seriously. For more info, please see Terms.

Twesh Mishra

A well written review. Opinionated and compelling the reader to actually read the book in concern. In a country where sex is still the greatest taboo, homosexuality is definitely worth pondering over. Still holding on to the crutches of morality, Indian societal structure is certainly in need of a social awakening to overcome the hypocrisy that has crippled it.

    Anushri Saxena

    Yes, the book does give an idea of the same. The protagonist is never able to openly talk about his sexual-orientation as he’d always wary of ‘what people would think..’ !
    No matter how urbanized we call ourselves, homosexuality is something everyone still looks down at.. or at least thinks differently about.


Hmm… thoughtful and insightful… the book sounds interesting. Definitely a sensitive topic, but a much needed bold move to sensitize the society to the LGBT Community

    Anushri Saxena

    Yes, bold indeed as I, personally had never come across any ‘Indian’ author pondering over such a topic..


Submit your story