Yes, The Uttarakhand Disaster Was Man Made!

Posted on July 2, 2013 in unEarthed

By Nicky Collins:

Blame is a lazy man’s way of making sense out of chaos. As I was reading about the devastating floods that have ravaged one of the most scenic states of our country, I could feel the familiar urge to point my finger at someone or something. Yes, at many points of our life, we do like to take the easy way out from a disaster by simply blaming it on others. But the floods in Uttarakhand prove to be a very complicated situation if you look at it closely.


The first finger, when it comes to even the tiniest detail of the weather, is always pointed at God. But I think, given that most of the stranded people in Uttarakhand are pilgrims, we can safely exonerate God for the deluge. From what I have observed, blaming is a much relished activity in India. The government, of course, is everybody’s favorite punching bag. Criticizing the government is seen as a dignified way of acquitting ourselves of any responsibility to the country. Sometimes the range of people we blame for our state of affairs is ludicrous – the neighbor who lives six floors down, your boss, the prime minister or even aliens and UFOs. In fact, the only person who is worse than the average Indian when it comes to blaming is Mamta Banerjee — if the floods had happened in West Bengal, she would have unhesitatingly blamed it on the CPM, no matter what common sense dictates.

But here, I would like to provide an alternative viewpoint. What if we, the normal citizens, do deserve some culpability in this matter? Of course, I am not suggesting that any of us have the power to control the weather. But what if we are indirectly a little bit guilty when it comes to natural disasters in general?

True, it is the hydroelectric projects constructed by the government that has resulted in the instability of the soil strata that probably compounded the effect of the floods. But who uses the power from these dams? We do. Who is ready to bite off the heads of those in the government if they do not get electricity? We are. Who raises a hue and cry if the power cuts are too long? We do.

The lush greenery that plays a very important role in stabilizing the ecosystem of the hilly areas is also being cleared because we need to build settlements. There is also a very good chance that the freaky weather these days is a result of the adverse impact of human activity on the environment which has resulted in global warming already.

In this entire issue, a sense of unity was conspicuous by its absence. I was disgusted by reports that stated that some locals were taking advantage of these floods by inflating the cost of basic items like food many times over. And if articles in leading newspapers are to be believed, pickpockets made a killing while people were fleeing for their lives.

Whatever way we look at this issue, it is obvious that we are at fault in some or the other way. And although the culpability is not very obvious, we all understand that it is there. That brings us to the main question, ‘Are the Uttarakhand floods a manmade disaster?’ You bet.


Nicky Collins

I am a very regular person in some ways and quite eccentric in many ways (almost bordering on psychotic or at least that is what my friends say). I have a lot of weaknesses but also a few strengths. People around me say I am a good debater ( and many judges in the competitions I have taken part in agree). But my English teacher says that my greatest strong point is my ability to laugh at myself. I have never doubted the veracity of the saying 'The pen is mightier than the sword'. But writing for me is not just a platform to make my views heard. It is also a source of pure joy. Moreover, writing is an unbiased platform - your reader judges you not on the basis of your color, looks or accent but only on the basis of your thoughts. I am presently interning with YKA because I like to make myself heard. And so far, I have had a great time.

Submit Your Story


You must be logged in to comment.


It was the dams that saved some of the large cities in those areas, so no the dams didn’t cause it . Why did it happen? Because it rained unusually heavily and there were too many people there. Simple.

    Nicky Collins

    I would like to clarify that I did not claim that the dams caused it. What I said was that the dams ‘compounded’ the effect of the flood.

    The ecosystems of hilly areas tend to be very fragile. So when you clear away a large amount of vegetation for the sake of hydroelectric projects, you are taking away the one thing that can alleviate the damage caused by floods. So I stand by what I have said in my article.

    However, I would like to remind you that my article is more concerned about our culpability than that of the dams.

bansi dhameja

उतरांचल की तबाही..माँगें खुदा से दुआएँ …bansi

पानी में बहते हुए देख अपनो को
कुच्छ भी कर ना पाए बचाने के लिए
कैसे भूल पाएँगे ये मंज़र वो ज़िंदगी भर
रह गये हैं लाश बन कर जीने के लिए

वो मॅगने गये थे दुआएँ ज़िंदगी की
किया पता था मौत से मुलाकात हो जाएगी
खो कर जो लौटे हैं घर अपनो को
लगता है उनको ज़िंदगी भर नीद नहीं आएगी

करता हूँ इलतजा अपने हुकूमरानो से अभी
भूल जाओ अपने अपने स्वार्थ सभी
कुच्छ तो सोचो करो मिलकर सभी
कुच्छ तो सोचो करो मिलकर सभी

करना तो उनके लिए कुच्छ हमें भी चाहिया
आओ उनके लिए माँगें खुदा से दुआएँ सभी
आओ उनके लिए माँगें खुदा से दुआएँ सभी

Paani men bahte huye dekha apno ko
Kuchh bhi kar na paye bachane ke liye
kaise bhool payenge ye manzar wo zindagi bhar
Rah gaye hain lash banker jeene ke lye

Wo Magne gaye the duayen zindagi ki
Kiya pata tha maut se mulakat ho jayegi
Kho kar jo laute hain ghar apno ko
Lagta hai Unko zindagi bhar need nahin aayegi

Karta hoon iltja apne hukumrano se abhi
Bhool jao apne apne swarth sabhi
Kuchh to karo milkar socho sabhi
Kuchh to karo milkar socho sabhi

Unke liye Karna kuchh to hamen bhi chahiya
Aao unke liye mangen khuda se duayen sabhi
Aao unke liye mangen khuda se duayen sabhi

Bansi (madhur)


    You want use to ask “khuda” for blessings for the victims? How about slapping khuda and demanding why he’s up this nonsense?

Shivanshi Asthana

i would like to say something here…its very easy to point fingers at anyone and everyone because its frustrating to c people dying of hunger and everyone being seemingly “helpless” about it…the prime minister says its the state govt responsibility..we say it the systems responsibility…but i do have the audacity to say that it is a man made disaster..n the reason is…overpopulation..whether it is the overcrowding at the railway ticket counters or the holy shrines..i kno that the govt isnt dng as much as it shud hav..but the fact matter how much we prepare for it..everything becomes so inadequate in this country because…forgive me but m sayin this….ppl are being born like cats and dogs.. we hav witnessed the allahabad sangam disaster not so long ago…n now this one..dont u think there should b a limitation on how many people per family shud b allowed …n that people who hav once visited these shrinesshud hav the common sense nt to visit them for recreational purposes and pollute the environmnt and add to the influx there?…this topic needs a serious consideration by the citizens….even more than the govt.nothing is gonna change until we change guys.

zoomi farookhi

i didn’t get the reason that exactly caused the floods in uttarakhand…, the dams or the increasing population…?

Similar Posts