Youth Ki Awaaz is undergoing scheduled maintenance. Some features may not work as desired.

U.P. Governor Ram Naik Says Those Who Don’t Chant ‘Bharat Mata Ki Jai’ Are “Dumb”

Posted on April 7, 2016 in News

By YKA Staff:

India's Petroleum Minister Ram Naik speaks during a media gathering in Bombay September 16, 2003. Naik said on Tuesday that state-run Indian Oil Corporation, Oil and Natural Gas Corporation and Gas Authority of India Limited will not be privatised. The minister addressed the news conference hours after a ruling by the Supreme Court asking the government to seek parliamentary approval for selling stakes in two state-run oil refineries, which he said was a historic decision. REUTERS/Sherwin Crasto SC/TW - RTR33GN
Image source: REUTERS/Sherwin Crasto

In remarks set to create more controversy, U.P. governor Ram Naik has said that those who did not chant Bharat Mata Ki Jai were “dumb”, the PTI reports. According to the PTI report, the governor made these remarks at a function in Pratapgarh, UP.

On the raging controversy over chanting of “Bharat Mata Ki Jai”, Naik said a handful of people are raking it up. “In 1950, Jana Gana Mana was made the National Anthem…there had been a tradition of singing the National Song and the Anthem in Parliament…very few people are raking up such issues…Everyone has the freedom to speak in democracy,” he said.

Earlier addressing a function here, he said, besides having academic knowledge, students should have knowledge of the country.

He said those not chanting ‘Bharat Mata Ki Jai’ were dumb.

He is not the first governor to have made such remarks during the tenure of the NDA government. Earlier, the governor of Assam P.B. Acharya had also created controversy by saying Muslims of India were free to move to Pakistan and Bangladesh.

Tathagata Roy, governor of Tripura, has also made certain remarks in the past which led to criticism.

The PTI report added that Naik has written a letter to Chief Minister Akhilesh Yadav in connection with the use of alleged unparliamentary remarks by senior minister Azam Khan against him.

“I have written a letter to the chief minister with reference to the unparliamentary comments of the parliamentary affairs minister Azam Khan…Akhilesh Yadav is presently on foreign trip. I will talk to him once he comes back,” Naik told reporters here.

In a CD handed over by the Assembly Speaker in connection with the matter, out of the 60 sentences of Khan, 20 have “unparliamentary comments”, although the Speaker says there is nothing undignified in it, the Governor said, adding that a meeting with the Speaker has been fixed for April 9.

Khan has been engaged in a no-holds-barred war of words with Naik for quite some time, with the minister accusing the Governor of being a “kar sevak” and “communally vitiating” the atmosphere in Uttar Pradesh at the “behest” of the Narendra Modi government at the Centre.

In a stinging remark in the Assembly, Khan had accused the Governor of stalling several bills by not giving his assent and alleged it was giving an impression he was working under the “influence of a party”.