By Cake Staff:
Calls for diverse media representation have exploded on Twitter with the hashtag #IStandForDiversity. It started on Sep. 5, 2016, as novelist A. C. Thomas tweeted out her frustration with multiple processes – from drafting, to scripting, to casting, to publishing – that have deliberately or negligently failed to include people of diverse race, ethnicity, body type, sexuality and more.
There’s nothing wrong w/ saying we’re tired of authors being silent. Marginalized ppl have dealt with a lot of crap lately in this community
— A.C. Thomas (@acthomaswrites) September 5, 2016
So excuse us if we think it would be nice if the authors we support spoke out in support of us every now and then.
— A.C. Thomas (@acthomaswrites) September 5, 2016
Nobody’s asking people to jump through hoops. Miss me with that BS. But if my fave is on here tweeting random stuff during a garbage fire…
— A.C. Thomas (@acthomaswrites) September 5, 2016
And I know they see it happening. There is no way they miss it. But for something as awful as this, they can’t just condemn that behavior?
— A.C. Thomas (@acthomaswrites) September 5, 2016
That’s not jumping through a hoop. That’s simply taking a stand. Silence makes racists, homophobes, and ableists bolder.
— A.C. Thomas (@acthomaswrites) September 5, 2016
#IStandForDiversity because I refuse to let anyone silence me.
— A.C. Thomas (@acthomaswrites) September 5, 2016
This came in response to a video by Bre Faucheux – one of Thomas’ peers in the industry. Faucheux, a fantasy and sci-fi author, had uploaded an anti-diversity “rant” to her YouTube channel on Sep. 2. In it, she expressed her discomfort with a [envoke_twitter_link]growing pressure on authors to make their novels more “diverse,”[/envoke_twitter_link] suggesting that it simply hinders the writing process. As a white woman, her “rant” simply came off as resistance towards addressing media’s lack of representation of certain identities. And honestly, it sounded a lot like when the MRAs claim that their lives have become difficult ever since women got rights. It also sounded a lot like a counterproductive reaction to one’s own white-guilt. All of this is possibly what ticked off Thomas in the first place, but she had no idea that hundreds would rally in her support:
https://twitter.com/acthomaswrites/status/772831205041459200
Twitter users had plenty to say about the media:
#IStandForDiversity because I don't wanna read about white straight cis able bodied characters anymore. I want someone I can relate to.
— ✨ (@feminizza) September 5, 2016
#IStandForDiversity because my kids — and all kids — deserve to see themselves as the heroes of the story. pic.twitter.com/5LY0QnAodn
— Sona Charaipotra (she/her) (@sona_c) September 5, 2016
#IStandForDiversity because the twelve-year-old girl I was shouldn't have waited until her twenties to have a book with a girl like her.
— Sailor Mer(kaye)ry Is Updates Only (@gildedspine) September 5, 2016
https://twitter.com/TristinaWright/status/772840209645993985
https://twitter.com/clairelegrand/status/772831028448784384
And the the argument took on other dimensions as well, such as diversity within LGBTQ spaces, that have often marginalized ‘lesser known’ queer identities:
#IStandForDiversity because I spent the first 23 years of my life thinking lack of sexual attraction meant I needed fixing
— Claudie (@ClH2OArs) September 5, 2016
#IStandForDiversity b/c maybe my WOC best friend wouldn’t have struggled so hard to figure out her sexuality if she’d seen positive bi rep.
— Erica Cameron (@ByEricaCameron) September 5, 2016
In fact, Thomas even tweeted a request to change the tag to #ISupportDiversity, when she realized the “stand” in the original was ableist. This further pushed the conversation to explore disability.
Then Came The Hijackers:
https://twitter.com/JSBTC/status/772843933533671424
#IStandForDiversity
I only EVER employ black trans women in wheelchairs.— Mark Gogglebox (@MarkGormIey) September 5, 2016
But Also Some Valid Criticism Of “Diversity” As A Concept:
This #IStandForDiversity hashtag is another Jedi mind trick that Black ppl need to watch out for.Because ppl use vague phrases about racism
— Tariq Nasheed 🇺🇸 (@tariqnasheed) September 5, 2016
The point being made here is that paying lip service is easy. In an earlier instance (though not quite related to Thomas’ hashtag), Oprah Winfrey and Ava DuVernay insisted on favouring the principle of ‘inclusion’ over diversity,’ and clearly there is scope for this conversation to evolve further.
But as a result of all of these discussions, [envoke_twitter_link]it is hoped that media, academics, workplaces and more will become just that – much more diverse[/envoke_twitter_link].