By Sourya Majumder:
News broke last morning that India had carried out a military operation across the Line of Control in Pakistan, following the attack at Uri. The attack by India is being referred to as a ‘surgical strike’ as they were precise strikes on specific camps (alleged to be terrorist camps). Twitter has been abuzz with the hashtag #surgicalstrikes, and the atmosphere of ‘nationalist pride’ that has been building up for some time now, fanned by several political parties, has found a very appropriate outlet. Reactions from India, including from several celebrities and media persons, mostly involved celebratory displays of pride, patriotism and congratulatory messages to the army. While it is is a must to condemn terrorism, jingoistic reactions should actually be cause for alarm, as war-mongering on social media and misguided public pressure can worsen this volatile situation.
However, while difficult to find, there were some balanced and cautious voices from both sides of the border asking for a more measured look at the events, and what they could escalate to. Here’s a look at some of the responses.
Many seemed to revel in jingoistic displays of pride:
https://twitter.com/iAnimeshS/status/781513360105873410
Finally! Good to see the forces celebrating. Great hit back! Well done Indian Army, and Modi for keeping your words sharp! #SurgicalStrike
— aboyob bhuyan (@aboyobbhuyan) September 29, 2016
https://twitter.com/adi7tiwari/status/781513325532237824
It gets worse…
East or West..
"Indian Army" is the BEST
Kudos to the #IndianArmy #WellDoneIndianArmy #MassiveRespect#ModiPunishesPak #SurgicalStrike— ..ಪ್ರಿಯಾ.. PRIYA 🇮🇳 (@PriJD641) September 29, 2016
#ModiPunishesPak Surgical strike celebration is treating as festival celebration.Everybody on Twitter is congratulating PM& Army!!!
— Prafull (@tprafull) September 29, 2016
https://twitter.com/PrahladVaishna8/status/781561153314971648
Karara jawab milega !!! #surgicalstrike #56inch #welldoneindianarmy in your face pakistan 😎#IndianArmy #DGMO
— Shaadi shuda Patarkar Popatlal (@Toofaanexpress) September 29, 2016
Haters gonna hate, no matter what
But elephant don't listen to the street dogs barking
Modi proved the #56inch by #SurgicalStrike— Shibya Pandey (@PandeyShivya) September 29, 2016
I am almost crying. Thank you @narendramodi ji for bringing these moments. #56Inch #ModiPunishesPak
— Rahul Kaushik (Modi Ka Parivar) (@kaushkrahul) September 29, 2016
Prominent celebrities, journalists, and politicians saw it as a strong response to terrorism:
Took Pak army several weeks to admit its soldiers were involved in Kargil misadventure Let's see how long it takes to accept #SurgicalStrike
— Rahul Kanwal (@rahulkanwal) September 29, 2016
Salute the Indian Army, for protecting our national security with a strong reply to the terrorists. #SurgicalStrikes #IndianArmy
— Sunny Deol (@iamsunnydeol) September 29, 2016
Thnx Indian army for the action against terrorism.V should all pray for safety & well being of our Indian soldiers. pic.twitter.com/7gltoNP937
— Shah Rukh Khan (@iamsrk) September 29, 2016
Namaskar. Mujhe garv hai hamare veer jawano pe,hamare pradhan matri ji aur raksha mantri ji pe. Jai Hind !Vande Mataram !
— Lata Mangeshkar (@mangeshkarlata) September 29, 2016
Salute to the #IndianArmy and government for taking such a strong and bold step. #surgicalStrike
— Nandish Singh Sandhu (@nandishsandhu) September 29, 2016
We sincerely congratulate the Central Government and our brave armed forces for the decisive action taken against terrorism.
— Nitish Kumar (@NitishKumar) September 29, 2016
Some were slightly more measured in their response:
We can debate the precise details of #SurgicalStrike, but here's the big picture: India has ended the failed policy of strategic restraint.
— Sadanand Dhume (@dhume) September 29, 2016
While at least a few voices advised caution and reflection:
Dear India this isnt a Akshay Kumar movie. #SurgicalStrike
— Zee ! (@wifi327) September 29, 2016
#SurgicalStrike
I know it was only retaliation after #UriAttack but I hope it stops at this and doesn't turn into a war.— prabhjot (@prabhablyy) September 29, 2016
As long as chance of escalation is high, I'd be cautious in my assessment of today's #SurgicalStrike. Too many people gushing too much.
— Raja راجہ – awaaz do, hum ek hain (@Raja_Sw) September 29, 2016
Other voices across the border warned of escalation:
Pakistan's response to kinetic aggression by India across LOC in Kashmir will be forceful. India has initiated a dangerous escalation.
— Mosharraf Zaidi (@mosharrafzaidi) September 29, 2016
Or were critical of typical nationalist reactions (a sentiment that, one feels, cuts across borders):
https://twitter.com/azadmohi/status/781513012633042944
And well, some extracted humour from the situation:
https://twitter.com/xtahzy/status/781441264768028672
Amidst all of this jingoistic celebration, let us not forget the actual toll war can take – on our economy, on our soldiers, on civilians on both sides of the border. It is more important now than ever to not spread misinformation, think clearly about the facts and the implications of a move like this, and reflect on where we might want to go in the future as a nation. Is more death and destruction what we really want?