Sexuality is fluid, and no matter how one might identify, experiencing attraction towards the same sex is absolutely valid. Even those who primarily experience heterosexual desire can be attracted to more than just the opposite gender – it really shouldn’t be cause for concern. But unfortunately, because patriarchy gives rise to harmful notions about what’s “masculine” and what’s not, cisgender heterosexual men do not find it easy to admit or even accept the fact they can be attracted to other men (even though it’s completely okay to be). But cisgender heterosexual women, however, find it easier to come clean about experiencing same-sex desire. Why is this so?
On October 18, 2016, Twitter user @mentalexotica set out to explore and try to answer this very question, trying to build a conversation around male sexual desire, and the various factors that forbid men from expressing it. In a series of tweets, she made some important points, and received a whole host of interesting and engaging responses from the men on her timeline.
She First Started Off With Some Simple Questions:
https://twitter.com/mentalexotica/status/788242391215935488
Part 2 of this line of questioning is: have you, as a straight man, ever experienced inexplicable sexual urges towards another man? Tell me
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
And Got Some Genuine Responses From Men:
@mentalexotica The lead character from one of my all-time favourite TV series, La Piovra. pic.twitter.com/AKIN4cirHm
— Nigel Britto (@NigelBritto) October 18, 2016
@mentalexotica I know a few men that I admire a lot and I always joke I’d date them in a heartbeat if I swung that way. They’re friends.
— Shivam (@GhantaGuy) October 18, 2016
@mentalexotica I had (have?) THE biggest crush on Raghuram Rajan. Dat smile combined with the fact that I want to pick his brain for days…
— Squeaky Riffcakes (@srikvlteswaran) October 18, 2016
But Some Responses Explored A Different Angle:
@mentalexoticapic.twitter.com/zA712DyTdh
— Krish (@thehistoryboy) October 18, 2016
Many of these showed that these men were hesitant to explore or verbalize the occasional desire they experience towards other men because of this same fear of breaching the kind of toxic masculinity they have been conditioned to internalize. This kind of a masculinity drives home that heterosexuality is the only form of expressing desire and anything otherwise disturbs the status quo.
By Now, She Was Curious:
The same sex crushes men have admitted to are of the fan/locker room variety. Still waiting for a man to admit to crazed lust for another
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
…And This Lead Her To Explore Masculinity In Greater Detail:
I’ve noticed a trend where women speak openly about experimenting with other women. We rarely recoil. We look on in distracted interest.
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
We don’t afford that sexual interest to men who may feel the same way. Our staunch beliefs in masculinity and all it represents prevents us.
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
Men should act a certain way. Walk, talk, sit, smoke & dress a certain way. Not smile too much. Frown so people know you mean business.
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
She Also Spoke About How Men Recoil From Fellow Male Affection:
If another man displays affection towards you shrug him off. If he hugs you a heartbeat too long, push him away and abuse him.
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
If a man talks about his feelings, displays vulnerability; if he tells you he loves you, it is your right to beat the shit out of him.
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
Our boys are not encouraged to have feelings. Or cry. Or love other men outside of family. There’s something very wrong in this soup.
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
The question I asked today was to glean how comfortable men were admitting their desires for other men. Not acting on it, just admitting it
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
And Made An Important Comparison Between Female and Male Same-Sex Relations:
Because girl on girl is such a flogged to death fantasy we can talk about it. No big deal. I kissed a girl and I liked it. Not so for boys.
— Like the Moon (@mentalexotica) October 18, 2016
Woman-on-woman love is often fetishized by the (straight) male gaze and seen as erotic. This stems from internalized sexism, and is yet another way of objectifying female bodies and female desire. But man-on-man love, in comparison, is seen as demeaning, is seen as ‘deviant’, because it is seen as a challenge to traditional gender dynamics. This is, indeed, a disturbing double standard.
What came out of this exercise was not just candid confessions from men who were forced to re-evaluate how they view their sexuality, how they deal with same-sex attraction, and how much of that is controlled by patriarchal conditioning. More importantly, it threw up questions about how men see other men, and how these responses can be deeply problematic. This was a dialogue that men in India (a country where notions of masculinity are truly toxic) sorely needed, and it was heartening to see so many men open up. This, indeed, is an important first step towards encouraging Indian men to be more comfortable with expressing emotion and desire.