“We live in a society where accidental birth determines your choices in life.”
Powerful words spoken by V. K. Madhavan of WaterAid India. Yes, we live in a country where the caste, class and gender you’re born into determines our choices, so much so that even [envoke_twitter_link]a decision to use the toilet is determined by our privilege[/envoke_twitter_link].
When we gathered for the #InDeepShit event organised by Youth Ki Awaaz and WaterAid India on April 22, we were all set to examine India’s sanitation crisis.
Join these 7 changemakers in finding solutions to India’s sanitation crisis at the #InDeepShit event. Register now! https://t.co/FlMRA9obmU pic.twitter.com/4WnqeY3teb
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 20, 2017
What began as a discussion around availability and access to toilets in the country, soon evolved into a one exploring how socio-cultural identifications influence how we can relieve ourselves.
Here are the 7 most important highlights from the event:
1. The Illegal Practice Of Forced Manual Scavenging Is A Harsh Reality For Many Even Today
Lalibai, a liberated manual scavenger and founder of the Rashtriya Garima Abhiyan, which works to empower and rehabilitate manual scavengers in the country, kickstarted the discussion by throwing light on the fact that [envoke_twitter_link]the illegal practice of manual scavenging is still a dark reality in India[/envoke_twitter_link].
“Upper caste people say ‘If you don’t work as a manual scavenger, you won’t be allowed to stay here.'” – Lalibai #InDeepShit
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
Lalibai shared, through personal anecdotes, how lakhs of rural women born into ‘lower’ castes are forced to take up the practice of manual scavenging by their families and villages, just so they can have meals on their table. When we say Swachh Bharat, then, are we not supposed to consider those who get down to the dirty work?
“We were told ‘if you don’t pick up people’s shit, how will you get money to eat?'” Lalibai shares her story of resistance. #InDeepShit pic.twitter.com/nRPRYpYd0h
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
2. We Need To Include Homeless People In Discussions When We Talk About Access To Toilets
“In a homeless shelter at Lodhi Road, there’s no attached toilet. Do homeless people not need toilets at night?” – @AlediaSunil #InDeepShit pic.twitter.com/S9kgjWyYBs
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
Sunil Kumar Aledia took the discussion forward with a talk on how [envoke_twitter_link]access to toilet facilities in the Indian context are also limited to the upper class[/envoke_twitter_link]/ caste context. When it comes to homeless people in Delhi, for instance, it’s almost as if we don’t think about them as people who need to answer nature’s call.
Toilets must be near the homeless and people with disabilities. Open defecation is dangerous and risky. – @AlediaSunil #InDeepShit
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
It’s simple. If homeless people don’t have access to toilets in the shelters built for them, where will they relieve themselves? How then, will the Swachh Bharat Abhiyaan fulfil its promise of making India open-defecation-free by 2019?
3. For People With Disabilities, Finding Accessible Toilets Can Be A Nightmare
Accessible toilets are practically impossible to find in the country. Nipun Malhotra, founder of the Nipman Foundation added much insight to the discussion at the event by sharing his perspective as a person with disability.
“I was refused a job because there were no disabled-friendly toilets at the company.” – @nipunmalhotra #InDeepShit pic.twitter.com/ThlhSc7rLj
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
Malhotra particularly stressed on the fact that [envoke_twitter_link]under the Swachh Bharat Abhiyaan, there is no incentive given to build disabled-friendly toilets[/envoke_twitter_link], particularly in rural areas. He concluded, “If other countries can be mindful of the needs of people with disabilities, why not India?”
Even in malls, disabled toilets are either locked or they become godowns for other shops. – @nipunmalhotra #InDeepShit
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
4. We Never Consider The Needs Of Gender Non-Conforming Persons When We Talk About Toilet Accessibility
With Section 377 being imposed, the queer community in India has become one of the most oppressed and disadvantaged communities in the country. As it is, [envoke_twitter_link]social stigma makes it hard for someone identifying as LGBT+ in the country to access the basics[/envoke_twitter_link] of education and job.
When gender non-confirming persons travel by metro, they are stared at, bodies are checked. Bathrooms also equally unfriendly. #InDeepShit
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
But, as Aastha Singh Raghuvanshi pointed out during the discussion, the queer community in India faces severe discrimination when it comes to accessing hygiene, as well. She also pointed out how, having a progressive law in place would not solve the issue, as it is also a deep behavioural change that needs to be effected for members of the LGBT+ community to access basic resources, including toilets, in India.
Some trans people also menstruate. Where is the safety for this section of society in toilets? Aastha R. discusses at the #InDeepShit event.
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
5. We Need Stricter Laws To Protect Those Who Are Implementing Swachh Bharat’s Mission And Cleaning Toilets
The second panel discussion started off on a fiery note, as Bezwada Wilson, the co-founder and National Convenor of the Safai Karmachari Andolan (SKA), took the mic. He began his talk by stressing first and foremost, that the Swachh Bharat Mission has been put in place as a business, a business that oppresses and systematically ignores the basic rights of those implementing it, that is, the cleaners.
How do we implement the law to the eradicate manual scavenging within the ambit of #SwachhBharat? @BezwadaWilson answers. #InDeepShit
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
Wilson went on further to highlight how with [envoke_twitter_link]98% of manual scavengers being women in the country[/envoke_twitter_link], sanitation is an issue that needs to be seen through the lens of caste and patriarchy.
“My family members cleaned shit. Patriarchy and caste force this system upon us.” @BezwadaWilson at #InDeepShit event pic.twitter.com/1xmPE1zzkv
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
6. Swachh Bharat Mission Needs To Account For Behavioural Change
With Yamini Aiyer from the Centre for Policy Research taking the discussion forward, we moved on to the topic of policy implementation. One key aspect she stressed on is the need for Swachh Bharat to focus on behavioural change, instead of solely focusing on building more toilets.
“Only 1% of budget saved for behavioural change spent under #SwachhBharat.” – Yamini Aiyar of @CPR_India #InDeepShit
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
Indeed, in a country where accessing toilets at will is a privilege only upper-caste, upper-class, heteronormative and non-disabled individuals enjoy, her words need heeding. Bipin Rai, of the Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board too, backed Aiyer’s words, adding that [envoke_twitter_link]maintenance is a key factor that Swachh Bharat needs to account for[/envoke_twitter_link].
Not just building toilets, maintenance and behavioral issues, also a concern for Swachh Bharat Mission- Bipin Rai #InDeepShit pic.twitter.com/Nv6koHfNbO
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
7. The Way Forward? Make Room For Diversified Discussions
As the second panel drew to a close, V. K. Madhavan concluded the discussion by stating that [envoke_twitter_link]the way forward for a Swachh Bharat is only through a change in mindsets[/envoke_twitter_link].
.@WaterAidIndia “If pipe water supply is the norm for us, why isn’t it for people in many urban slums and villages?” – V. K. Madhavan #InDeepShit
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
We need to recognise our privilege and stand with and speak for those who weren’t born into upper class/caste households.
“The issue today is that the government is systematically denying the very existence of manual scavengers!” –@vkmadhavan #InDeepShit pic.twitter.com/gVO95UOFbd
— Youth Ki Awaaz (@YouthKiAwaaz) April 22, 2017
And finally, [envoke_twitter_link]we need open, free spaces for discussion[/envoke_twitter_link] on these topics, where together, we can all discard the cloak of privilege and move towards a truly cleaner, healthier India.